Open your Facebook Ads dashboard, then your Google Ads dashboard, and add up the sales each one says it drove. For a lot of small businesses, that total is bigger than the number of sales you actually made. Both platforms are taking credit for the same customers.
That’s by design. Ad platforms count a sale as theirs if someone saw or clicked an ad before buying. They don’t ask whether that person was going to buy anyway.
Where the extra credit comes from
Three kinds of ads are especially good at taking credit:
Retargeting. Ads shown to people who already visited your site. Many of them were coming back regardless.
Branded search. Ads on your own business name. Someone typing your name into Google already knows who you are.
Repeat customers. Your regulars see your ads, then buy like they always do, and the ad gets the credit.
None of these ads are useless. The problem is that the dashboard can’t tell you how much of that revenue they actually created.
The question that matters
The question that matters: “How many sales would I have lost if this ad didn’t run?” Marketers call this incrementality. It’s the difference between people who saw your ads and similar people who didn’t.
A simple test you can run
You don’t need a data science team. Here’s a version any local business can try:
Pick one campaign. Start with retargeting or branded search, where over-counting is most common.
Write down your baseline. Note your total weekly calls, bookings, or sales for the last four weeks, from your own records, like your booking calendar, call log, or register.
Pause it for two to three weeks. Keep everything else the same, so you aren’t changing prices, running a sale, or launching something new.
Compare. If your real totals barely move, that campaign was mostly taking credit. If they drop, it was doing real work.
For businesses that serve more than one area, a cleaner version is to pause ads in one city or ZIP code and keep them running in a similar one, then compare the two.
What to do with the answer
If a campaign turns out to be mostly taking credit, shrink it and move that budget toward ads that reach people who don’t know you yet. That’s usually where new customers come from.
Then test again. Markets change, seasons change, and what worked last spring might not work this fall.
Want help finding out what your ads are really doing? That’s exactly what our free audit covers.